Leave The Key Homebuyers
CLAIM YOUR PROFILEMid-Island Property Solutions, LLC, trading as Leave The Key Homebuyers, is a cash buyer based in Amityville, with partner Benjamin Wagner (BBB; its site lists Larry and Ben Wagner as owners) and a BBB business start of December 2019. Its record is consistent: the founding date matches, a single address appears everywhere and BBB accreditation is in place. The trade-off is disclosure: it publishes no day count and no offer method, and does not say in writing whether it is the end buyer. Ask them this before you sign: “Will Mid-Island Property Solutions, LLC take title itself, or can this contract be assigned to another buyer?”
Active Since
2019
Est. Closing
“On your timeline”*
Est. Offer
Not published
Deal Volume
“Hundreds” of homeowners
company-stated
*Est. Closing is quoted from the company’s own site. Est. Offer shows only a percentage the company publishes itself; none of the ranked buyers publishes one.
Is Leave The Key Homebuyers a fit for your sale?
Leave The Key Homebuyers may be worth comparing if its service area, property focus, and written terms match your needs. Availability and final terms depend on your property and ZIP code.
Potential strengths
- Founding date matches across BBB and Google, and one Amityville address appears everywhere
- BBB A+, accredited since November 21, 2023
- 5.0 Google rating from 71 reviews, checked October 25, 2026
- Names multifamily, tenant-occupied and inherited or probate homes
What to confirm
- No day count: “We close on your timeline”
- No offer method beyond “a fair cash offer”
- Does not say in writing whether it is the end buyer
Coverage
Leave The Key Homebuyers serves long island, brooklyn, queens, staten island and listed upstate cities. Property eligibility varies by location, home type, condition, and current buyer capacity.
Published service area
Long Island, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island and listed upstate cities
Availability check
Confirm your property address
Enter your property address in the offer form to check available buyers. A request may include Leave The Key Homebuyers or another buyer serving the area.
Transaction details
Review the timeline and written terms for your specific property. The figures below are profile estimates, not a guaranteed offer or closing date.
- Entity
- Mid-Island Property Solutions, LLC (d/b/a Leave The Key Homebuyers)
- Address
- 230 A Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701
- Business start
- December 13, 2019 (BBB)
- Service area
- Long Island, Brooklyn and other listed areas
- Model
- Not stated explicitly
- Offer method
- “A fair cash offer”; no inputs named
Reviews and verification
We separate sourced ratings from company-stated information. No customer score is displayed until a publishable source is available.
Google rating · 71 reviews · checked Oct 25, 2026
5.0
Google, checked October 25, 2026. Ratings belong to the platform’s reviewers, not Cash-Match. Pulled on the date shown.
Profile status
Design preview
Company details and performance figures shown here are illustrative until independently sourced and reviewed.
Fees and process
Ask for an itemized written offer showing every fee, credit, deduction, inspection condition, and closing obligation.
Share your property details
Start with the address and a few details about the home and its condition.
Review the written offer
Check the proposed price, deductions, conditions, and who will be named as the buyer.
Confirm the timeline
Agree on inspection, closing, and move-out dates before signing.
Compare before deciding
Consider the expected proceeds and obligations alongside your other selling options.
No verified seller-fee schedule has been supplied for this preview. Confirm total proceeds and all seller-paid costs in the final agreement.
Frequently asked questions
Confirm these details in writing before deciding whether an offer fits your sale.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Will Mid-Island Property Solutions, LLC take title itself, or can this contract be assigned to another buyer?
Compare the offer, not just the promise.
Review pricing, conditions, and timing before choosing your next step.